SBS Law PLC

Grand Rapids Partnership, Shareholder & LLC Member Dispute Attorneys

Home / Business Law & Litigation / Partner, Shareholder & LLC Member Disputes

Have you found yourself in a major dispute with your business partners about your company’s operations or allegations of misconduct? If so, you know that your business’s growth and reputation are on the line, and that time is of the essence. Don’t let a dispute escalate to the point that a positive resolution becomes impossible. Instead, contact SBS Law PLC for an initial case review with a knowledgeable Grand Rapids business lawyer. We’ll discuss how we can help you seek a positive outcome that best protects your rights and interests.

Disputes Between Business Owners in Michigan

SBS Law PLC represents business owners in disputes with the people they own the business with: partners in a partnership, members of a limited liability company, and shareholders of a closely held corporation. We represent owners who have been shut out or shortchanged, and owners and companies accused of doing it. We handle these disputes from the first demand letter through negotiation, mediation, arbitration and trial.

Owner disputes are handled by the firm's litigation division, led by partner Todd Stuart, with partner John Burns, who heads the firm's federal litigation, and Michael J. Harris, of counsel.

We are based in Grand Rapids and represent clients in Kent County, Kalamazoo County and across West and Southwest Michigan.

How Owner Disputes Start

Most businesses with more than one owner begin on trust. The owners know each other, the work is divided informally, and the agreement, if there is one, was signed at the start and not looked at again. A dispute starts when circumstances change: the business makes real money or starts losing it, one owner does more of the work, someone wants to sell, or a family member or a new investor enters.

These disputes are harder than an ordinary contract case because the owners are bound to each other. They share bank accounts, customers, employees and debt, and they usually cannot just walk away. Under Michigan's partnership statute a partner who profits from partnership business without the others' consent holds that profit as a trustee for the partnership (MCL 449.21), and Michigan courts describe the duty partners owe each other as one of the utmost good faith and integrity (Band v Livonia Associates, 176 Mich App 95 (1989)). The same expectation runs through the law on LLCs and closely held corporations. What follows explains what each kind of owner can demand, and what a court can do.

What Business Owners Fight About

  • Money. Whether profits are paid out or kept in the business, what the owners pay themselves, and who has to put in more capital.
  • Control and deadlock. Two owners, or two equal sides, cannot agree, and nothing in the agreement breaks the tie.
  • Being shut out. An owner is refused the books, left out of decisions, removed from management or fired from a job at the company.
  • Misuse of the business. An owner is accused of taking company money, property or opportunities for personal use.
  • Leaving, or being forced out. An owner wants out, or the others want that owner out, and the sides disagree about the price.

The Agreement Comes First

Most of these disputes turn on a document: the partnership agreement, the LLC's operating agreement, or a corporation's bylaws and shareholder agreement. It usually decides who votes on what, when money is distributed, whether an owner can sell or be bought out and at what price, and whether a dispute goes to court or to arbitration.

Michigan's statutes fill in what the agreement leaves out. So we read the agreement before anything else. If you are setting one up or revising one, see partnership, shareholder and LLC membership agreements.

Your Rights Depend on the Kind of Business

Partnerships

Under Michigan law a partnership is two or more persons carrying on a business for profit as co-owners (MCL 449.6). No filing or written agreement is needed, so people are sometimes partners without having decided to be. Unless the partners have agreed otherwise, they share profits equally and have equal rights in managing the business (MCL 449.18). That is true even when one partner put in more money or does more of the work, which surprises many people.

The statute also protects a partner's access to information. Every partner may inspect and copy the partnership's books at any time (MCL 449.19), and partners must give each other true and full information about the partnership on demand (MCL 449.20). A partner who has been wrongfully excluded from the business has the right to a formal account of its affairs (MCL 449.22). In a partnership dispute the first step is usually a written demand for the books.

Limited liability companies

An LLC is governed first by its operating agreement, and many of the rights below can be changed by it. A member may withdraw from an LLC only as the operating agreement provides (MCL 450.4509), so an unhappy member usually cannot resign and demand to be paid. On written request, a member is entitled to the company's most recent annual financial statement and tax returns, and may inspect and copy its records (MCL 450.4503). A manager must act in good faith, with the care an ordinarily prudent person would use in a like position, and in a manner the manager reasonably believes to be in the company's best interests (MCL 450.4404).

Corporations

On written request, a shareholder is entitled to the corporation's balance sheet and income statement for the last fiscal year. A shareholder may also inspect its books and records for a proper purpose, after a written demand that describes the purpose and the records. If the corporation does not allow the inspection within five business days, the shareholder may ask the circuit court to order it (MCL 450.1487). Directors and officers owe the corporation the same duties of good faith and care that an LLC's managers owe the company (MCL 450.1541a).

Shareholder and Member Oppression

A member of an LLC, or a shareholder of a corporation whose shares are not publicly traded, may sue in circuit court to show that the people in control have acted illegally, fraudulently, or in a way that is willfully unfair and oppressive to the company or to that owner (MCL 450.4515 for LLCs; MCL 450.1489 for corporations).

Both statutes define willfully unfair and oppressive conduct the same way: a continuing course of conduct, or a significant action or series of actions, that substantially interferes with the owner's interests as an owner. It can include firing an owner or limiting an owner's employment benefits, to the extent that interferes disproportionately with that owner's distributions or other interests as an owner.

It does not include conduct that the operating agreement, the bylaws, the articles, another agreement the owner is party to, or a consistently applied written company policy permits. That is one more reason the agreement is read first.

Michigan courts read "willfully" to require intent. The owner must show that the people in control meant to interfere with the owner's interests, and a legitimate business reason can defeat the claim (Franks v Franks, 330 Mich App 69 (2019)). There is no right to a jury in these cases; they are tried to the judge (Madugula v Taub, 496 Mich 685 (2014)).

What a Court Can Order

If an owner proves illegal, fraudulent or oppressive conduct, the court may grant the relief it considers appropriate. The remedy most owners ask for is a buyout: an order that the company, or the owners responsible, purchase the owner's interest at fair value. The statutes say "fair value", which is not the same as fair market value. Whether the price is reduced because the interest is a minority one, or because there is no ready market for it, is left to the judge (Franks v Franks, 330 Mich App 69 (2019)). That makes the valuation of the business the center of most of these cases.

The court has other tools as well. It can award money damages to the company or to the owner. It can order the company or the people who run it to do something, to change it or to stop. It can cancel or change a provision of the articles, the bylaws or the operating agreement. And it can dissolve the company and liquidate its assets (MCL 450.4515(1); MCL 450.1489(1)).

Separately from an oppression claim, a court can end a business that can no longer function. It can dissolve a partnership when a partner's conduct makes it not reasonably practicable to carry on the business with that partner, or when other circumstances make dissolution equitable (MCL 449.32). It can dissolve an LLC that is unable to carry on business in conformity with its articles of organization or operating agreement (MCL 450.4802). And it can dissolve a corporation whose directors or shareholders are deadlocked on material matters or cannot elect directors, so that the corporation cannot function effectively (MCL 450.1823).

Closing the business is rarely the goal. Most owners want to be paid fairly, or to keep the business and part ways with a co-owner. What a court could order shapes what the two sides will agree to.

Deadlines Are Short

These claims have shorter deadlines than a contract claim. A suit for damages for oppression must be filed within three years after the claim arises, or within two years after the owner discovers it or reasonably should have, whichever comes first (MCL 450.4515(1)(e); MCL 450.1489(1)(f)). The same three-year and two-year limits apply to a claim that an LLC's manager, or a corporation's director or officer, failed in the duties described above (MCL 450.4404(6); MCL 450.1541a(4)).

The clock starts when the people in control interfere with the owner's interests, not when the loss shows up later. Whether a longer period applies when an owner asks only for a buyout or another order, and not for money, has not been settled by the Michigan Supreme Court (Frank v Linkner, 500 Mich 133 (2017)).

If you think you are being shut out, do not wait to find out where you stand.

Where and How These Disputes Are Resolved

Many owner disputes end in a negotiated buyout or a mediated agreement, without a lawsuit; see resolving partnership disputes without going to court. Negotiation works best when each side knows what a court would be likely to order, which is why we assess the legal position before we open talks.

Some agreements require arbitration, and the clause can take in claims like these. The Michigan Supreme Court sent a former principal's whole dispute with the people running his firm, including his claim under the LLC statute, to arbitration under the operating agreement's clause (Altobelli v Hartmann, 499 Mich 284 (2016)).

When a case is filed in Kent County, a dispute between a business and its owners goes to the circuit court's business court (MCL 600.8031, 600.8035). For the courts and the steps of a case, see our business litigation page. If the dispute is about a broken buy-sell or other contract between owners, see breach of contract litigation.

What to Bring to a First Conversation

  • The partnership agreement, operating agreement, bylaws, shareholder agreement and any buy-sell agreement, with every amendment
  • The articles of organization or incorporation
  • Recent tax returns, K-1s and financial statements for the business
  • Records of what each owner has put in and taken out
  • Emails, letters and texts with the other owners about the problem
  • A short timeline of what happened and when
  • What you want out of it: to stay, to be bought out, to buy the other owner out, or to close the business

Questions Business Owners Ask

We never signed a partnership agreement. Do I have any rights?

Yes. Michigan's Uniform Partnership Act supplies the rules when partners have not agreed on their own: an equal share of the profits, an equal say in management and access to the books (MCL 449.18, 449.19).

My business partner wants to buy me out. What are my options?

Start with the agreement. Many operating and shareholder agreements say when an owner can be bought out and how the price is set. If yours does not, the price is a matter for negotiation, and a valuation of the business is usually where that starts. Have the offer and the agreement reviewed before you answer.

I own a minority share and I have been shut out. What can I do?

Ask for the company's records in writing; the statutes above give you that right. If the people in control are acting illegally, fraudulently or oppressively, a court can order the remedies listed above, including a buyout of your interest at fair value.

Can I be fired from a company I partly own?

It depends on your agreement and on why it happened. Michigan's statutes say that firing an owner can be oppression to the extent it interferes disproportionately with that owner's distributions or other interests as an owner (MCL 450.4515(2); MCL 450.1489(3)).

Do you represent majority owners or minority owners?

Both. We represent owners bringing these claims and the owners and companies defending them.

Talk With Our Litigation Attorneys

If you are in a dispute with a business partner or co-owner, or see one coming, call SBS Law PLC at 616-333-2427 or send us a message. Tell us what happened and what you need, and we will tell you how we can help.

Practice Areas