SBS Law PLC represents owners who are selling a business, and people and companies who are buying one, in West Michigan. Most of these are sales of privately owned companies: a shop, a restaurant, a practice, a contractor, a manufacturer. We handle the transaction from the letter of intent through due diligence, the purchase agreement and the closing.
This work is handled by partner Todd Stuart, who also heads the firm's litigation division. He has seen in court what happens when a purchase agreement left a question open, and he negotiates and drafts with that in mind.
This page follows a sale in the order it happens, first for the seller and then for the buyer. Our mergers and acquisitions page goes further into the law behind each step.
We are based in Grand Rapids and represent clients in Kent County, Kalamazoo County and across West and Southwest Michigan.
A privately owned business is usually sold in one of two ways. The choice comes first, because it decides what the buyer is responsible for, what has to be transferred, and what the seller still has to do after closing.
The buyer, often through a new company formed for the purpose, buys the things that make up the business: equipment, inventory, the name, the customer list, the contracts and the goodwill. The seller's company goes on existing and keeps whatever was not sold. The general rule in Michigan is that a buyer of assets does not take on the seller's liabilities (Foster v Cone-Blanchard Machine Co, 460 Mich 696 (1999)). The rule has exceptions, set out below under “When a buyer of assets is still liable.” For the seller, the general rule means the debts the buyer does not agree to take stay with the seller's company, which still has to deal with them after the sale.
The buyer purchases the stock of a corporation, or the membership interests of an LLC, from its owners. Nothing is transferred out of the company. It holds the same assets, contracts and employees the day after closing as the day before. It also owes the same debts, including ones nobody knew about. The buyer's protection is what it learns before closing and what the sellers promise in the agreement.
Each form is taxed differently, and differently for the buyer than for the seller, so the price is often negotiated with the form in mind. In a purchase of the assets of a business, federal tax law requires the price to be allocated among the assets, and an allocation the buyer and seller agree to in writing binds both of them unless the IRS finds it is not appropriate (26 U.S.C. § 1060). The allocation belongs in the purchase agreement, and each side's accountant should see it before anyone signs.
A serious buyer will ask for several years of financial statements and tax returns, the lease, the main contracts, the licenses, and the company's own records showing who owns it. Gather them first and read them as a buyer would. A problem the seller raises costs less than one the buyer discovers.
Before a seller opens its books, the buyer signs an agreement not to disclose or use what it learns. It protects the seller if the deal does not close, which many do not.
The letter of intent sets out the main terms: the price, the form of the deal, what is included, how long the buyer has to investigate, and whether the seller may talk to other buyers in the meantime. Whether it binds the parties depends on the intent they expressed, and where that is unclear it is a question of fact for a court. A contract to make a later contract is not unenforceable for that reason alone, though it can fail if an essential term is missing (Opdyke Investment Co v Norris Grain Co, 413 Mich 354 (1982)). So a letter meant only as a framework should say so in plain words, and should say which of its provisions, usually confidentiality and exclusivity, are meant to bind.
A sale is not valid simply because the person across the table agreed to it. A sale of all or substantially all of a corporation's assets, outside the usual and regular course of its business, has to be submitted to the shareholders and approved by the holders of a majority of the outstanding shares entitled to vote (MCL 450.1753). Unless the operating agreement says otherwise, a sale of all or substantially all of an LLC's assets outside the ordinary course of business may be authorized only by a vote of the members (MCL 450.4502(6)), and a merger requires the unanimous vote of the members entitled to vote (MCL 450.4702(1)). Operating agreements often change these rules, which is why the agreement is one of the first documents we read. Owners who are selling their shares or membership interests should read the shareholder agreement, the operating agreement and any buy-sell agreement before they sign anything, to see what those documents say about a sale to an outsider.
The seller states facts about the business in the agreement: that the financial statements are accurate, the taxes are paid, the equipment is owned free of liens, there are no undisclosed claims. If one of those statements proves false, the indemnification section says what the buyer can recover, for how long, and up to what amount. These sections decide who pays when something surfaces a year after closing, and they are where most of the negotiation happens. Part of the price is often held in escrow for a period to stand behind them.
The price may be paid in full at closing, partly over time on a promissory note, or partly as an earn-out that depends on how the business performs afterward. A seller who finances part of the price should take a security interest in the assets sold and file a financing statement with the Secretary of State to perfect it (MCL 440.9310(1), 440.9501(1)), and usually asks the buyer's owners for a personal guaranty. An earn-out needs a precise formula and a statement of how the buyer must run the business while it is being measured, because a vague one is a lawsuit in waiting.
A person who is liable for a tax under Michigan's revenue act and sells out the business must make a final return within 15 days after the date of the sale (MCL 205.27a(1)). The same statute makes the buyer hold in escrow enough money to cover the business's unpaid taxes, interest and penalties until the seller produces the Department of Treasury's receipt or certificate, as explained below. Treasury tells a buyer what is owed only with the seller's written consent, and it has up to 60 days to answer, so it helps a seller to file promptly and sign that consent early.
An asset sale leaves the seller's company in existence. It holds the sale proceeds, and it still owes the debts the buyer did not take on. Most owners then close the company. The law sets the order: creditors first, owners after.
A corporation may be dissolved by action of its board and shareholders. The dissolution is approved if it receives the vote of the holders of a majority of the outstanding shares entitled to vote on it, and it is carried out by filing a certificate of dissolution (MCL 450.1804). A dissolved corporation continues to exist, but it may not carry on business except to wind up its affairs: collecting its assets, selling what is not to be distributed to its shareholders, and paying its debts (MCL 450.1833). Before it distributes assets to its shareholders, it must pay or make provision for its debts, obligations and liabilities (MCL 450.1855a).
An LLC is dissolved when the members entitled to vote unanimously vote for dissolution, or when a vote of the members or another event named in its articles of organization or operating agreement takes place (MCL 450.4801). An LLC dissolved in either of those ways files a certificate of dissolution when it begins winding up (MCL 450.4804(1)). When it winds up, its assets are distributed to creditors first and to the members after them, and before any distribution it must file the tax returns and pay the taxes required by the state revenue act (MCL 450.4808).
This is the buyer's investigation: financial statements and tax returns, contracts and leases, licenses, employees, lawsuits and claims, liens, and title to any real estate. Its purpose is to find out whether the business is what the seller says it is before the price is paid, and to find the problems the agreement will have to deal with.
Buying the assets instead of the company limits what the buyer takes on. It does not eliminate it. Two of the checks made in every purchase are below. Our mergers and acquisitions page covers them at more length, along with the seller's unemployment insurance account and the liens on what is sold.
A person who buys a going or closed business, or its stock of goods, must hold back in escrow enough money to cover the seller's unpaid Michigan taxes, interest and penalties until the seller produces a receipt from the Department of Treasury showing the taxes are paid, or a certificate that none are due. A buyer who does not is personally liable for those taxes, up to the fair market value of the business less what was paid to secured creditors with priority. With the seller's written consent, Treasury will tell the buyer what the business is known or estimated to owe within 60 days, and a buyer who escrows that amount is not liable for more (MCL 205.27a(1)). Sixty days is longer than many closings take, so we ask for the tax clearance early.
A buyer who pays cash for assets is not liable for the seller's liabilities unless one of five narrow exceptions applies: the buyer expressly or impliedly agreed to assume them; the transaction amounts to a consolidation or merger; the transaction was fraudulent; some element of a good-faith purchase was missing, or the transfer was made without consideration and the seller's creditors were not provided for; or the buyer is a mere continuation or reincarnation of the seller (Foster, 460 Mich at 702-703). The risk is greatest where the same people own and run the business before and after the sale and only one company is left operating.
In an asset purchase each contract the buyer wants has to be assigned to it. Many contracts, and most commercial leases, forbid assignment without the other party's written consent, and a clear clause of that kind is enforced. The landlord's consent is often the item that sets the closing date. Many licenses and permits belong to the seller and do not pass with the assets; the buyer applies for its own.
In an asset purchase the seller's employees do not become the buyer's employees automatically. The buyer decides whom to hire and on what terms, and the agreement should say who pays the wages, commissions and time off earned before closing. In an equity purchase the employer does not change, so employment continues, along with whatever the company had already promised its people.
The owners of the company that is selling often have to approve, and a buyer should see proof that they did.
At closing the price is paid, the assets or the ownership interests are transferred, liens are paid off and released, and the escrows are funded. The work continues afterward: transferring licenses and accounts, changing or releasing names with the state, a transition period in which the seller helps the buyer, and any part of the price that is paid over time.
Most disagreements after a sale are about the same few things: a statement in the agreement that turned out not to be true, an adjustment to the price, an earn-out, or the seller's agreement not to compete. We handle those disputes as well; see breach of contract litigation.
Bring what a buyer will ask to see, and what you have been offered so far.
Bring whatever is on paper, even if nothing is signed.
Most buyers of small businesses buy the assets, because they choose what they take and leave most of the seller's liabilities behind. Buying the company can be the better course where a contract, a license or a lease would be hard to move. Sellers often prefer to sell the company. The answer depends on the liabilities, the transfers required and the tax result for each side.
They stay with your company. Even if the buyer agrees in the purchase agreement to take a debt, your company stays liable to that creditor until the creditor agrees to release it. The law can also hold a buyer liable for a seller's debts in the narrow cases described above, under “When a buyer of assets is still liable.” A lender with a lien on the assets is normally paid at closing so that the lien can be released. The rest are for the company to pay, and it has to pay or provide for them before it distributes what is left to its owners.
Nearly every buyer asks for it. That is what the non-compete in the purchase agreement is for. Michigan enforces a reasonable one given by the seller of a business. Its length, territory and scope are negotiated like the price, and a seller should agree only to terms the seller can live with.
Then the purchase agreement is the first thing a court reads. We handle those disputes as well; see breach of contract litigation.
If you are thinking about selling your business or buying one, or have a letter of intent in front of you, call SBS Law PLC at 616-333-2427 or send us a message. The earlier we see the deal, the more of it can still be shaped. Tell us what the business is and where things stand. We will tell you how we can help.